Appleton Signature Blend Rum (1.75L)
From Nassau Valley, St. Elizabeth, Jamaica

90-95WE

The first nosing passes find gentle scents of light spice and brown sugar; aeration reveals solid aromas of molasses and buttered toast. The palate entry is delicious, rich and toasty; the midpalate features elegant flavors of toasted honey-wheat bread, honey and refined sugar. The finish is more bittersweet than sweet.

90-95 points, Wine Enthusiast (2008)

$29.99

12 bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
$29.99

7 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Captain Morgan Private Stock Rum (1.75L)
From St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands

$40.99

10 bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
$27.99

13 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Cruzan Coconut Rum (1.75L)
From St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands

$19.99

29 bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
Flor de Cana 15yr ECO Rum (750ml)
From Managua, Managua, Nicaragua

$44.99

3 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Malibu Peach Rum (750ml)
From Saint Michael, Barbados

$13.99

7 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Ronrico Gold Rum (1.75L)
From Arecibo, Puerto Rico

$14.99

12 bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
Sailor Jerry 92° Spiced Rum (1.75L)
From United States Virgin Islands

$20.49

60+ bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
$13.99

31 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$21.99

1 bottle in stock and ready to ship.
1
Bacardi Superior Rum (375ml)
From Cataño, Puerto Rico

91WE Top 50

Clean and classic, from the citrusy aroma to the light, crisp flavor with endnotes of ginger and coriander. Add handfuls of mint and stir up a pitcher of mojitos.

91 points, Wine Enthusiast (Aug 2012)

Wine Enthusiast Top 50 Spirits of 2012

$8.99

21 bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
Big 5 Coconut Rum (750ml)
From New Port Richey, Florida

$17.99

5 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Black Tot Finest Caribbean Rum (750ml)

91BTI

Amber color. Aromas and flavors of vanilla sea salt caramels, scorched toffee and over ripe bananas, fermented pineapple, and honey bun with a round, dry medium-to-full body and a long finish revealing notes of very ripe banana, pineapple upside down cake, caramel sauce, and marzipan. Rich and tropical with earthy undertones, this will make an excellent Dark & Stormy.

91 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Apr 2023)

$59.99

5 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Captain Morgan Spiced Rum (375ml)
From St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands

89WE

It’s become fashionable to hate on the Captain, but the original in the spiced-rum category has a pronounced vanilla scent accented with clove and allspice notes. The sweet caramel flavor is one-dimensional, but it’s easy to see why it’s endured all these years: Mixed with Coke (or other mixers) and lots of ice, it blends right in and becomes easy sipping.

89 points, Wine Enthusiast (Aug 2011)

$9.99

48 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
This item is a 375ml half bottle. Did you intend to order a half bottle?
Chuckle Rum (750ml)
From Florida

$17.99

7 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Diplomatico Distillery Collection No. 1 Batch Kettle Rum (750ml)
From Venezuela

89BTI

Medium amber color. Creamy, toasty aromas and flavors of caramelized banana, creme brulee, and roasted nuts in a cedar bowl with a satiny, vibrant, dry-yet-fruity medium-to-full body and a warming, complex, long finish that exhibits touches of toffee, sweet and peppery spices, cola float, and minerals finish. A silky and artfully balanced dark with deep flavors and superb versatility.

89 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Jun 2018)

$76.99

1 bottle in stock and ready to ship.
1
Diplomatico Distillery Collection No. 2 Barbet Rum (750ml)
From Venezuela

87BTI

Brilliant amber color. Aromas of tobacco, candied mango, banana cream puff, butterscotch, animal crackers, and cinnamon with a glycerous, lively, off-dry medium body and a peppery, engaging, medium-length allspice, jerk seasoning, lime leaf, and marzipan finish. A spicy dark rum for sipping and cocktails; perfect for a dark and stormy!

87 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Jun 2018)

$76.99

1 bottle in stock and ready to ship.
1
Gold's Liquors White Rum (750ml)
From New Port Richey, Florida

$16.99

4 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Hampden Estate Pagos Rum (750ml)
From Wakefield, Trelawney, Jamaica

$89.99

4 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Mount Gay 1703 Andean Oak Cask Rum (750ml)
From Bridgetown, Saint Michael, Barbados

$199.99

4 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Pere Labat 40 Rhum Agricole (750ml)
From Guadeloupe, France

$33.00

1 bottle in stock and ready to ship.
1
Plantation 3 Stars Silver Rum (1L)
From Barbados

93BTI

Clear color. Aromas and flavors of lemongrass, butcher’s paper, salted caramel, and mocha with a soft, bone-dry light-to-medium body and a long finish that exhibits overtones of vanilla, black pepper, banana leaf, and marzipan and plantains. Extremely light, clean, and supremely mixable; a benchmark column still white Rum.

93 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Mar 2023)

$19.99

1 bottle in stock and ready to ship.
1
Sailor Jerry 92° Spiced Rum (375ml)
From United States Virgin Islands

$8.99

17 bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
$39.99

4 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$15.49

10 bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
$18.99

24 bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
$15.99

7 bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
$15.99

1 bottle in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
$15.99

4 bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.