Gosling's Family Reserve Old Rum (750ml)
From Bermuda

95WE

The bouquet changes dramatically within the 10-minute nosing period from a baked aroma to an earthy, spicy, woodsy aroma. The palate entry is smooth, intensely oaky, yet semisweet; at midpalate the sweetness picks up in the forms of honey and molasses. Concludes elegantly, satiny smooth in the throat, and properly bittersweet.

90-95 points, Wine Enthusiast (Dec 2005)

$79.99

2 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Bacardi Pineapple Rum (750ml)
From Cataño, Puerto Rico

$12.99

8 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Flor de Cana 25yr Centenario Rum (750ml)
From Managua, Managua, Nicaragua

$149.99

2 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Cruzan Pineapple Rum (750ml)
From St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands

$10.99

6 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Rhum Barbancourt 4yr 3 Star Rum (750ml)
From Port-au-Prince, Ouest, Haiti

$23.99

11 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Captain Morgan Spiced Rum (Plastic Traveler) (750ml)
From St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands

89WE

It’s become fashionable to hate on the Captain, but the original in the spiced-rum category has a pronounced vanilla scent accented with clove and allspice notes. The sweet caramel flavor is one-dimensional, but it’s easy to see why it’s endured all these years: Mixed with Coke (or other mixers) and lots of ice, it blends right in and becomes easy sipping.

89 points, Wine Enthusiast (Aug 2011)

$12.99

38 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Cruzan Dark Rum (750ml)
From St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands

89BTI

Pale amber color. Aromas of toasted coconut and mocha walnut fudge with a silky dryish medium body and a creamy flan, cedar, wet stone and peppery spice finish. A rock solid gold rum.

89 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Jun 2011)

$10.99

13 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Bacardi Reserva Ocho Rum (750ml)
From Cataño, Puerto Rico

91WE

Aged for a minimum of eight years, this full-bodied amber rum has a fruity scent with a hint of vanilla and sweet caramel flavor with a baking spice finish. Smooth feel. A good choice for mixing into cocktails.

91 points, Wine Enthusiast (Nov 2011)

$29.99

5 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Captain Morgan Coconut Rum (750ml)
From St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands

$11.99

44 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$19.99

7 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$34.99

3 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Ron Carlos Light Dry Rum (1L)
From United States Virgin Islands

$7.99

9 bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
$27.99

4 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Bacardi Reserva Limitada Rum (750ml)
From Cataño, Puerto Rico

94BTI 93WE

Golden amber color. Attractive aromas and flavors toffee and sweet cream with a satiny medium-to-full body and a rich, brown spice, sweet tobacco and mineral driven finish. A deliciously rich and flavorful rum.

94 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Jun 2013)

Give this velvety, golden amber rum a few minutes to open up, and it shows warm vanilla and almond aromas. Most of the flavor is on the finish: gentle vanilla bean, banana and coconut tones. Makes for a nice sipping rum.

93 points, Wine Enthusiast (Dec 2011)

$99.99

2 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Cruzan Raspberry Rum (750ml)
From St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands

85-89WE

The raspberry aroma after the pour is true-to-the-source, ripe and fresh; following aeration the aroma turns more preserves-like than fresh-picked fruit-like. Palate entry is sweet, yet tart and pleasantly fruity; by midpalate the flavor profile turns savory, fruity and decidedly sweet/tart. Concludes elegantly and ripe. Another how-to lesson on rum flavoring by the wizards at Cruzan. Best Buy.

85-89 points, Wine Enthusiast (May 2005)

$10.99

6 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Blue Chair Bay Banana Rum Cream (750ml)
From Brighton, Saint Michael, Barbados

$18.99

5 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Blue Chair Bay Coconut Rum (750ml)
From Brighton, Saint Michael, Barbados

88BTI

Clear. Very dimension coconut flake frosting and gelatin aromas with a sweet, silky light-to-medium body and a delicate coconut cream and waxy white chocolate finish. A tasty coconut rum for cocktails.

88 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Jun 2013)

$18.99

10 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Bacardi Lime Rum (750ml)
From Cataño, Puerto Rico

$12.99

8 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Diplomatico Mantuano Rum (750ml)
From Barquisimeto, Lara, Venezuela

94BTI

Dark amber color. Baked, complex aromas and flavors of banana bread, walnut skin, Mr. Pibb, and desert wine with a lightly tannic, bright, dryish full body and a tingling, elaborate, medium-long hazelnut spread, cherries in dark chocolate, leather jacket, and spicy oak finish. A great special occasion rum.

94 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Apr 2017)

$24.99

7 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$39.99

2 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
DonQ 151° (750ml)
From Ponce, Puerto Rico

$22.99

12 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Cruzan Tropical Fruit Rum (750ml)
From St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands

$10.99

9 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$29.99

6 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Bacardi Coconut Rum (750ml)
From Cataño, Puerto Rico

85-89WE

A balanced approach to the coconut flavoring; aeration allows delightful, low-key and unsweetened coconut perfume to appear. Palate entry is moderately sweet and coconut-like; by midpalate, the coconut flavor turns drier and crisper. Finish is long, and savory. Terrific in any piña colada.

85-89 points, Wine Enthusiast (Jul 2003)

$12.99

2 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
La Favorite Ambre Rum (1L)
From Fort-de-France, Martinique, France

$39.99

9 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Mount Gay Black Barrel Rum (750ml)
From Bridgetown, Saint Michael, Barbados

94WE Top 50

Finished in “deeply toasted and charred” Bourbon casks, this mouthwatering small-batch rum skews to the sweeter side, offering bold notes of cola, allspice and vanilla, finishing brisk and spicy. Sip straight or mix for the ultimate rum & Coke.

94 points, Wine Enthusiast (Aug 2014)

Wine Enthusiast Top 50 Spirits of 2014

$39.99

13 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Sailor Jerry 92° Spiced Rum (750ml)
From United States Virgin Islands

$13.99

15 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Bacardi Black Rum (750ml)
From Cataño, Puerto Rico

89WE 87BTI

A deep and dark rum, with a nut-brown color and sweet toffee and hazelnut aroma. Strong alcohol presence on the palate, but that washes over with toffee and coconut and a hint of cinnamon. If rum and cola is your tipple of choice, this cola-like rum should make a fine match. Aged “upward to four years.”

89 points, Wine Enthusiast (Dec 2011)

Amber brown color. Aromas of salty butter roasted nuts and chocolate raisins with a supple, fruity-yet-dry medium body and a creamy flan, mineral and pepper finish.

87 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Jun 2013)

$11.99

3 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Diplomatico Planas Rum (750ml)
From Venezuela

93BTI

Pale slivery straw color. Aromas of coconut confection, sweet corn, banana cream, vanilla taffy, and citrusy tonic water with a satiny, vibrant, dry-yet-fruity light-to-medium body and a warming, medium-long saline, lime blossom, and allspice finish. A tidy rum well-suited to Cuba Libres.

93 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Mar 2018)

$24.99

6 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Havana Club Anejo Blanco Rum (750ml)
From Cataño, Puerto Rico

$21.99

13 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1