Easily one of the most revered estates in all of California wine, Shafer is synonymous with Napa Valley, and particularly the striking (and strikingly expensive) Pritchard Hill terroir, which shines brightly once again in this range of show-stopping expressions that speak to the legendary pedigree of the estate and the elite skills of winemaker Elias Fernandez.
Of course, the towering 2021 Cabernet Sauvignon Hillside Select is another tour de force performance for this original California luxury blue chip, with no fewer than four 99-point reviews. "The 2021 Cabernet Sauvignon Hillside Select is insanely beautiful," exclaimes Antonio Galloni, "It's also one of the very finest wines I have ever tasted here." Jeb Dunnuck has the "ultra-classic, focused, structured 2021" among the best Hillsides ever, a sure bet for collectors looking to stock their cellars with all-time greats. By all indications, the 2023 Napa vintage is also shaping up to be one for the ages, and the 2023 Cabernet Sauvignon One Point Five is a hit once again, for its ability to translate the heart and soul of this remarkable estate for a fraction of the price of the Hillside. "Deep, pliant and resonant in the glass," the 2023 nails the quintessential character of the 2023 growing season with real style and distinction, resulting in rock-solid press led by a 96-point review from Jeb Dunnuck, who calls it a "classic, serious wine" that even touches on a bit of Pauillac spirit for a sterling, benchmark display of Napa Cabernet brilliance.
The "exceptionally bright" 2023 Cabernet Sauvignon TD-9 nails the quintessential character of the growing season with real style and distinction, resulting in "rock-solid" press led by a pair of 95-point reviews from James Suckling and Jeb Dunnuck. It's becoming increasingly rare to find such benchmark examples Napa Cabernet brilliance at under $60, which makes this a perfect opportunity to savvy buyers to stock up. Finally, fans and collectors of the estate will tell you that the Chardonnay is always one of the best buys in the range. The "standard-bearer" for non-malo Napa Chardonnay according to Wine Advocate, the 2024 Chardonnay Red Shoulder Ranch has already racked up serious press from all corners, topped by 95 points from James Suckling, and Antonio Galloni writes, "The 2024 Chardonnay Red Shoulder Ranch is a very pretty, elegant wine ... All the elements are so well balanced." It's no wonder this exceptional vineyard excelled in 2024 - it's a perfect expression of what the Carneros micro-climate offers in this kind of growing season, and a classic example what this wine offers to Napa Chardonnay fans.
As you can clearly see, Shafer is firing on all cylinders, as always, and these current releases are all must-have trophies and gems that any serious Napa aficionado should be adding to their cellars without hesitation,
This has a lovely core of fruit with aromas of nectarines, grilled lemons and flint. The midweight, textural palate shows balanced acidity, finishing with a slight phenolic grip. Moving out of the cooler 2023 bottling, this is far more generous and open. Drink or hold.
95 points, James Suckling (Sep 2025)
For fans of Chardonnay without malolactic fermentation, Shafer's 2024 Chardonnay Red Shoulder Ranch remains a standard-bearer. Ripe pineapple, pear and honeysuckle mark the nose, while the full-bodied palate is loaded with opulent mango fruit that's expansive and lush but brought back into focus on the crisp citrus-and-green-apple finish.
94 points, Joe Czerwinski, Wine Advocate (May 2026)
The 2024 Chardonnay Red Shoulder Ranch is a very pretty, elegant wine. Lemon confit, white flowers, mint and light tropical inflections are some of the many notes that grace this weightless, super refined Chardonnay. All the elements are so well balanced. There is a feeling of understated lightness here that is so appealing.
94 points, Antonio Galloni, Vinous (Nov 2025)
Juicy pears, fresh apricots, and apple tart scents sail from the glass of the 2022 Red Shoulder Ranch Chardonnay, followed by nuances of cedar, honey toast, and nutmeg. Full-bodied, the palate has a lovely satiny texture and beautifully knit freshness supporting the generous orchard fruit flavors, finishing long and spicy.
94 points, Lisa Perrotti-Brown, Wine Independent (Aug 2025)
Based on multiple clones and aged in 30% new French oak with no malolactic fermentation, the 2024 Chardonnay Red Shoulder Ranch was bottled in July and offers tons of tropical fruits, honeysuckle, sweet lemon, and tangerine notes. It's medium-bodied, pure, and nicely balanced, with the fresh, fruity style of the vintage. Drink 2025-2037.
93 points, Jeb Dunnuck (Dec 2025)
Bold and intense, mingling a laser beam of acidity with flavors of ripe, salted melon, mandarin orange, mango puree and apricot at the core. A whiff of fennel pollen, tarragon and dried lemongrass adds aromatic intrigue. Drink now. 5,000 cases made.
93 points, MaryAnn Worobiec, Wine Spectator (Feb 2026)
Intriguing and attractive, this Chardonnay balances rich flavors with mouthwatering length for a succulent and enticing wine. Aromas and flavors of ripe white nectarine and peach, apple skin, and pithy accents of white and pink grapefruit entwine with well-integrated spices.
93 points, Elaine Chukan Brown, Wine Enthusiast (Dec 2024)