"Escala Humana remains one of the Uco Valley's most compelling projects." - Matthew Luczy, Wine Advocate
Argentina's wine scene remains one of the most dynamic in the world, with new upstart projects making serious waves. Among the best is Escala Humana, Germán Masera and Ayelén Bonetto's artisan operation from exceptional old vines. The 97-point 2023 Credo Sémillon is one of finest examples of the varietal in the New World, from a single parcel of high-elevation, 120-year-old vines and vinified in three separate press loads. Matthew Luczy of Wine Advocate sees two decades of potential evolution due to its "depth, delicacy and persistence in equal measure with remarkable symmetry."
The double 96-point 2023 Credo Malbec from the El Peral parcel, an 85-year-old parcel on alluvial soils from the valley floor, is "a gorgeous expression of the classic yet contemporary profile one can routinely expect from the Credo line at Escala Humana." It's an expansive yet finessed version that offers pure Malbec excellence, showing the full measure of one of Argentina's most talented new winemaking teams. All in all, this duo is stunning addition to the country's collectible scene
Deep and compressed on the nose. Harmonious and fresh, showing salted lemons, seashells and briny fruit with a hint of white honey, white nuts and nougat. Medium-bodied, concentrated and mildly flinty yet subtle and composed. Long and pure. From extremely old vines, some dating back to 1891, with an average age of 100 years. Drinkable now, but much better in the next 20 to 25 years. 1,234 bottles.
97 points, Zekun Shuai, James Suckling (Jun 2026)
The 2023 Credo Sémillon originates from vines planted in El Peral in 1895 and combines multiple vinifications of free-run juice and skin-contact fermentation in concrete eggs before maturing for two winters in new and used barrique. A deep golden color introduces a fantastically pure bouquet of orchard fruits, white flowers, vanillin, dried herbs and beeswax, followed by a rich, textural, buoyant and focused mouthfeel. It concludes with a soaring, lifted finish that slowly grows more expansive as it unfolds, regenerating depth, delicacy and persistence in equal measure with remarkable symmetry. It is already drinking quite well, but as I find consistently with the 2023 vintage, I suspect it will benefit from a bit more time in bottle to further congeal, then it should evolve gracefully into its second decade.
96 points, Matthew Luczy, Wine Advocate (Aug 2026)