A dense and old-school pinot noir, as it should be, with dried strawberries, cedar and spice as well as hints of chocolate. Full and layered. Solid tannins. Drink or hold.
94 points, James Suckling (Jan 2024)
The Estate Pinot Noir from Chalone, aged nine months in 35% new French oak, stands out as one of the most polished and delicious Pinot Noirs from this iconic estate in recent years. Vibrant cherry fruit takes centre stage, accompanied by clove, violets, and rose petal notes, layered with rich brown spices. A medium-bodied richness unfolds on the palate, supported by expressive mineral tension reminiscent of wet slate and graphite. The finish lingers beautifully, offering fashionable bramble and mountain herb nuances. It is a truly elegant and balanced wine that captures the essence of Chalone's distinctive terroir.
94 points, Jonathan Cristaldi, Decanter (Dec 2024)
Earthy aromas of toasted wood and coffee meet with dusty boysenberry on the nose of this bottling from the historic producer in its eponymous appellation. The palate is rich with baked berry and spicy in star anise and clove flavors, as oak hits on the finish.
93 points, Matt Kettmann, Wine Enthusiast (Jul 2024)