"Vintage after vintage, Casanova di Neri continues to impress. The 2021s bring a seductive energy to the house’s complex, ripe style." - Eric Guido, Vinous
Long-time winemaker and owner Giancarlo Neri has fashioned his estate into one of Montalcino's most decorated (and sometimes controversial) names. As Giancarlo's illustrious career comes to an end and his son Giovanni takes the reins, there's been a wait-and-see approach the past few vintages as regards the estate's direction. Well, any questions can be put to rest in the epic 2021 vintage, as the flagship expressions are knockout, critically acclaimed stunners, capped by a perfect score for the iconic Tenuta Nuova. "It’s a gorgeous Tenuta Nuova that has everything working in harmony and will only improve with time in bottle." notes Jeb Dunnuck's Italy critic, Audrey Frick. Showing "a humbling level of complexity," the 2021 is built on an irresistible tension between its full aromatic and flavor profile and its ultra-precise, energetic structure, which Frick notes in detail in her 100-point review. Several 98-point reviews put the coda on this latest stunner, which marks a watershed moment in the evolution of this great estate.
As great as Tenuta Nuova is, you can expect the 2021 Brunello normale to take things to another level as well. With numerous 95-point reviews to its credit, the 2021 is a resounding triumph for this bottling that will stand with many other estates riservas when all is said and done. "The complexity here is off the charts and the energy is incredible," exclaims Eric Guido of Vinous. Fans of the estate will also find plenty to love in the 2023 Irrosso, a JS92 value gem that offers up plenty of di Neri pedigree at an easy case-buy price. Keen-eyed collectors will notice a handful of bottles of the highly limited 2020 Brunello Giovanni Neri, a double 98-point cellar "showstopper" from a 50-year-old parcel near Castelnuovo dell' Abate. "I do love the intensity and the energy of this wine," notes Wine Advocate's Monica Larner.
The entire range of new releases from Casanova di Neri shows an iconic estate that is far from resting on its laurels, instead pushing boundaries on a mission to maintain its place in the very elite echelon of Montalcino's most esteemed names.
The 2021 Brunello Di Montalcino comes from a warm but not extreme growing season, helped by timely rain and a normal harvest window. It pours a deep ruby red hue and opens with black raspberries, violets, fresh earth, licorice, and rosemary. Medium to full-bodied, it feels more vertical and energetic than the 2020, with a bright spine of acidity, well-defined tannins, and a long, focused finish that stays light on its feet. Drink 2026-2040.
95 points, Audrey Frick, Jeb Dunnuck (Feb 2026)
The 2021 Brunello di Montalcino is an understated beauty, mixing dusty rose and lavender with shavings of blood orange and black cherries. It is surprisingly juicy yet elegant and refined, as ripe wild berry fruits slowly drench the palate in primary concentration. Structured and dramatically long, the 2021 finishes spicy and intense with nuances of citrus, clove and licorice. The complexity here is off the charts and the energy is incredible.
95 points, Eric Guido, Vinous (Nov 2025)
A soft and crunchy wine with plenty of red cherry, light chocolate and orange peel aromas and flavors. Medium-bodied with creamy, open-grained tannins and a savory, juicy finish. Drink or hold.
95 points, James Suckling (Dec 2025)
Not to diminish Casanova di Neri’s single-vineyard offerings, but in 2021, my money is on the white label. This bottling brings together the estate’s historic parcels in the cool district of Torrenieri, and it will need a few more years before unveiling its full potential. For now, traces of damp earth, black tea and cinnamon bark transpire with coaxing. The tight and sinewy frame guards the fruit closely but allows gorgeous floral perfumes to slowly seep out. Fine, chalky tannins are long and tactile. Very zesty too.
95 points, Michaela Morris, Decanter (Nov 2025)
This is vibrant and boasts pure cherry, strawberry, floral and mineral flavors. Elegant and fluid through the midpalate, where a layer of dense, assertive tannins emerges. The finish is long, and overall this feels balanced. Best from 2029 through 2046. 7,900 cases made, 3,300 cases imported.
94 points, Bruce Sanderson, Wine Spectator (Jun 2026)
The Casanova di Neri 2021 Brunello di Montalcino shows dark fruit flavors of plum and soft berry. A glossy texture lends polish and shine to the mouthfeel, while the wine delivers medium-lean weight and moderate length with good brightness and freshness. Aging sees 42 months in large oak casks. This bottling represents the estate’s classic, multi-vineyard village expression, designed to balance consistency, accessibility and regional typicity. Production totals 94,800 bottles.
93 points, Monica Larner, Wine Advocate (Jan 2026)