Old Overholt 4yr Straight Rye Whiskey (750ml)
From Clermont, Kentucky

85-89WE

The first sniffings detect notes of black pepper and oak resin; aeration adds stone-dry scents of minerals, slate, and sage. The palate entry is lean, semisweet, intensely grainy, and satisfying; at midpalate the whiskey lies well on the tongue, sweet, grainy, medium plump, and spicy. Finishes spicy. A very solid rye whiskey that deserves a larger audience.

85-89 points, Wine Enthusiast (May 2006)

$17.99

11 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Rowan's Creek Bourbon (750ml)
From Bardstown, Kentucky

92WHA

Beautifully balanced, like Kentucky Vintage, but more complex and with greater depth. It’s also not as boldly dry as Pure Kentucky XO. Rather, it is softer and more seductive. This is splendid bourbon! It would be a shame to adulterate this bourbon in any way-don’t even think of mixing it. Find yourself a quiet moment, pour yourself a measure, and savor.

92 points, Whisky Advocate (Vol. 14, #2)

$49.99

8 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Select Tennessee Whiskey (750ml)
From Lynchburg, Tennessee

94WE

At first, this whiskey is easy to underestimate, since the amber color and mild toffee aroma give little away. But one sip, and it is clear this whiskey means business: Deep vanilla cookie and cigar tobacco flavors unfold to a big, burnt-caramel finish, which washes over the palate like a rolling wave. Manhattan-worthy.

94 points, Wine Enthusiast (Mar 2011)

$47.99

44 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Michter's US*1 Small Batch Sour Mash Whiskey (750ml)
From Bardstown, Kentucky

93WE

Resurrected after 23 years, this smooth, buttery American whiskey is worth the wait. It has mellow vanilla and oak flavors, with a faint cherry essence on the long finish that seems to urge, “stir up a few Manhattans already.”

93 points, Wine Enthusiast (Jul 2013)

$45.99

25 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$59.99

3 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$26.99

3 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
1792 Small Batch Bourbon (750ml)
From Bardstown, Kentucky

$25.99

60+ bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Michter's US*1 Small Batch Bourbon (750ml)
From Bardstown, Kentucky

90-95WE

Bouquet opens with aromas of hazelnut, asphalt, fennel, steamed asparagus and damp hay; additional air contact adds metallic/botanical fragrances that suggest lead pipe, rust, popcorn, dill, brine and charred oak. In the mouth, loads of rich, maple-like flavors delight the tastebuds. Finishes softer than I expected.

90-95 points, Wine Enthusiast (Dec 2003)

$45.99

17 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$64.99

42 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Noah's Mill 114.3° Bourbon (750ml)
From Bardstown, Kentucky

96WA

Remarkably silky, as smooth as cashmere and creamy textured, this bourbon offers lots of smoky marmalade, caramel, toffee and new saddle leather-like characteristics. It is a fabulous, intriguing, distinctive bourbon.

96 points, eRobertParker.com (May 3, 2013)

$89.99

5 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
1792 Full Proof Bourbon B-21 Single Barrel Select (750ml)
From Bardstown, Kentucky

92WHA

No age statement on the label, but aged for 8 1/2 years. Bottled at the same ABV as its entry proof into the barrel. Lush and mouth-coating. A pleasingly sweet bourbon, with caramel, nougat, and chewy toffee, mixed with ripe orchard fruit, golden raisin, and creamy vanilla. Soothing finish. A wonderful way to end a meal. (With a cigar, perhaps?) This is a beautiful bourbon and a great value given its quality, ABV, and price.

92 points, John Hansell, Whisky Advocate (Fall 2016)

$54.99

24 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Bulleit Bourbon (750ml)
From Lawrenceburg, Kentucky

95WE Top 50 93BTI

Golden and bright, this straight Bourbon whiskey is one of the most versatile around. Though it starts with a sweet flavor profile with hints of vanilla and cookie dough, it finishes supple and dry, with notes of leather, black tea and cinnamon. Bracing alcohol levels.

95 points, Wine Enthusiast (Jul 2013)

Wine Enthusiast Top 50 Spirits of 2013

Brilliant amber color. Dense aromas of lacquered sandalwood, melted vanilla toffee, clay, and pickling spices with a plush, satiny medium-full body and a rich, chewy dried fruit pastry, mineral and warming spice flourish. An finely etched and balanced bourbon for sipping or cocktails.

93 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Feb 2012)

$23.99

60+ bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Jack Daniel's Winter Jack (750ml)
From Lynchburg, Tennessee

$15.99

26 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$39.99

3 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon (750ml)
From Lawrenceburg, Kentucky

93WE 90BTI

Aromas are sweet and fruitcake-like, with faint cigar smoke. Restrained, subtle flavors of orange peel, cinnamon and leather ride a medium-to-heavy body. The finish is extremely smooth, with a touch of anise.

93 points, Wine Enthusiast (Sep 2010)

Bright amber color. Aromas of lacquered wood, creme brulee, roasted whole nuts, and honeyed fruit cake with a soft, dry-yet-fruity medium body and a smooth, nicely balanced finish. A rock solid everyday bourbon that is sure to please.

90 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Feb 2013)

$29.99

29 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Michter's US*1 Unblended American Whiskey (750ml)
From Bardstown, Kentucky

94WE Top 50

This small-batch whiskey is a treat, butter-soft and loaded with sweet toffee and hazelnut aromas and flavors. The long finish rolls toward dry espresso and mocha flavors, pepped up with clove and cinnamon.

94 points, Wine Enthusiast (Jul 2012)

Wine Enthusiast Top 50 Spirits of 2012

$45.99

21 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$49.99

7 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Wild Turkey Longbranch Bourbon (750ml)
From Lawrenceburg, Kentucky

$29.99

60+ bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$40.99

34 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Hooten Young 12yr American Whiskey (750ml)
From Jacksonville, Florida

$64.99

4 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Maker's 46 Bourbon (750ml)
From Loretto, Kentucky

94WE

The nose finds supersweet deep caramel candy and almond extract, but don’t be fooled. On the tongue, it’s punch-in-the-nose dry and biting. Best served on ice, which takes down the burn and lets the pronounced woody flavors come through: lots of oak, strong tea and cigar tobacco.

94 points, Wine Enthusiast (Sep 2010)

$34.99

60+ bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Woodford Reserve Rye (750ml)
From Louisville, Kentucky

93WE

The latest addition to the Woodford line has a sweet aroma, evoking allspice, root beer and caramel. The palate shows plenty of vanilla and caramel but finishes bracingly dry and spicy, with bitter chocolate, clove and a tongue-numbing touch of cayenne.

93 points, Wine Enthusiast (Jul 2015)

$31.99

12 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Breckenridge Bourbon (750ml)
From Breckenridge, Colorado

90WHA

WHACK! The spicy smack of the nose sends me to check the mashbill; sure enough, this is 38% rye. The nose fumes with youthful zest: cinnamon, bright mint, sun-warmed green grass. Pour some on the palate for more explosive entertainment; sweet cinnamon red-hots burst, corn pops, and the oak burns on into the rye-high finish. This is one excitable boy of a bourbon, and it’s got me humming along. Impressive.

90 points, Whisky Advocate (Advance: Summer 2013)

$39.99

2 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Old Forester Mint Julep (1L)
From Shively, Kentucky

$19.99

1 bottle in stock and ready to ship.
1
Chattanooga Cask 111 Whiskey (750ml)
From Chattanooga, Tennessee

$42.99

10 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$67.49

7 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$17.99

6 bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
Jim Beam Black Label Bourbon (750ml)
From Clermont, Kentucky

95WE 93BTI

Honey/amber hue. Opening nosings detect sweet notes of light caramel, toffee and yellow fruit; aeration stimulates baked, dry aromas of tobacco leaf, oak resin and breakfast cereal. Palate entry is firm, semisweet and mildly grainy; by midpalate, there’s a slight oiliness to the texture that I like while the taste becomes narrowly focused on the grain/wood interplay. Finishes elegantly, emitting more dry than sweet flavors of toasted grain and oak. Best Buy.

90-95 points, Wine Enthusiast (Dec 2003)

Amber color. Robust aromas of caramelized nuts, melted chocolate, dried stone fruits, and delicate baking spices with a supple, fruity-yet-dry medium-to-full body and a long cola, praline cookie, cedar, and mineral finish. A great sipping or mixing whisky.

93 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Feb 2013)

$19.99

15 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Wild Turkey Kentucky Spirit B-21 Single Barrel Select Bourbon (750ml)
From Lawrenceburg, Kentucky

93BTI

Golden amber color. Herbal aromas of toasty cornbread, dill, tobacco, crushed peanuts, grass clippings, cocoa, and caraway with a round, lively, fruity medium body and a warming, interesting, medium-long chocolate covered toffee, cherry preserve, polished furniture, black peppercorns, and menthol finish. A super-solid bourbon with herbal inflections that will make for a nice old-fashioned cocktail to ponder.

93 points, Beverage Testing Instititue (Aug 2018)

$59.99

60+ bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
George Dickel Sour Mash Classic Recipe (750ml)
From Cascade Hollow, Tennessee

$19.99

14 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1