Ron Centenario 7yr Anejo Especial Rum (750ml)
From San José, San José, Costa Rica

$17.99

29 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$29.99

30 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Cockspur VSOR Rum (750ml)
From Bridgetown, Saint Michael, Barbados

$29.99

4 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Brinley Gold Shipwreck Spiced Rum (750ml)
From St. Kitts, Saint Kitts and Nevis

89WE 88BTI

Some spiced rums are merely colored, not aged; but this nut-brown spirit is made from a base of rum aged for four years in oak barrels. With that context, the boozy and slightly Bourbon-like toffee aroma makes perfect sense. Needs a little time in the glass to open up the flavors, but the reward is a sweet, subtly clove- and ginger-spiced spirit with a bitter almond finish.

89 points, Wine Enthusiast (Aug 2011)

Pale amber color. Fruity and spicy aromas of honeyed cherries and citrus peels and vanilla with a zesty, off-dry medium body and a praline and peppery spice finish. An attractive and well flavored spice rum.

88 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Jun 2013)

$25.99

8 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Ron Barcelo Gran Anejo Rum (750ml)
From Santo Domingo, National District, Dominican Republic

87BTI

Amber color. Yeasty raisin scone and white toffee aromas with a silky, dry-yet-fruity medium body and a black walnut ice cream, mineral, straw and delicate spice finish. Tasty and very mixable.

87 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Jul 2012)

$19.99

6 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Zaya Gran Reserva Rum (750ml)
From Trinidad and Tobago

$24.99

17 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Cruzan Vanilla Rum (750ml)
From St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands

$10.99

60+ bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$32.99

21 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$26.99

20 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
El Dorado 21yr Special Reserve Demerara Rum (750ml)
From West Demerara, Guyana

95WE

Aeration allows aromas of oak, winter holiday spice and vanilla cake frosting to emerge. Supple palate entry, moderately honeyed; midpalate highlights include the buttery/creamy texture and tastes of cocoa, fiber, ash and beans. Sophisticated and world-class.

90-95 points, Wine Enthusiast (Aug 2007)

$109.99

13 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Cruzan Black Cherry Rum (750ml)
From St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands

90-95WE

The ripe and beguiling cherry scent bouquet is strikingly kirsch-like. At entry, the taste is delicate with ripe cherry flavors, elegant and integrated; the delicious taste continues into the midpalate phase as the creamy texture coats the tongue in rich and genuine black cherry flavor. Finishes a touch metallic, but is still a smashing flavored rum.

90-95 points, Wine Enthusiast (Sep 2008)

$10.99

18 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Ron Abuelo 7yr Anejo Rum (750ml)
From Pese, Pese District, Panama

93WE 92BTI

Made with a blend of rums aged seven years, this silky spirit has an amber color and warm toffee aroma. On the palate, this rum is relatively dry, with clove and cinnamon spice and a lingering vanilla note. Good alcohol balance, just enough for structure.

93 points, Wine Enthusiast (Dec 2011)

Brilliant amber color. Lush aromas of coconut creme brulee, melted chocolate, roasted nuts, dried tropical citrus and baking spices follow through on a round, supple entry to a dry-yet-fruity medium-full body with tremendous depth and gusto. Finishes with a very long, evolving fade of coconut cream, banana custard, cocoa, tobacco and spice. A fantastic sipping rum, or use for sensational artisan cocktails.

92 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Dec 2009)

$24.99

5 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Malibu Coconut Rum (750ml)
From Saint Michael, Barbados

$12.99

60+ bottles in stock for in-store purchase.
Available in-store only.
Papa's Pilar Dark Rum (750ml)
From New York, New York

91WE

Developed in conjunction with Ernest Hemingway’s estate, this deep, dark rum blended in the Solera style and finished in Spanish Sherry casks will satisfy tipplers with a sweet tooth. It reads almost like a spiced rum—soft and sweet, with notes of brown sugar, toffee, sasparilla and allspice, though it also has some dry aspects on the finish, showing baking spices, leather and dark chocolate.

91 points, Wine Enthusiast (Aug 2013)

Inspired by the boundless travels of Ernest Hemingway, Papa’s Pilar Dark boasts a bold mouth, long finish and a complex flavor profile, hell-bent on returning rum to its gutsy roots. This artisan-crafted spirit is sourced from hand-selected rum spanning the Caribbean, U.S. and Central America, aged up to 24 years, and solera blended by our master blending team in Bourbon barrels, Port Wine casks, finishing in Spanish Sherry casks. Papa’s Pilar Dark is bold and well-traveled; just like Papa.

Distillery Notes

$37.99

8 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Parrot Bay Key Lime Rum (Plastic Traveler) (750ml)
From St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands

$9.99

6 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Ron Barcelo Imperial Rum (750ml)
From Santo Domingo, National District, Dominican Republic

90BTI 85-89WE

Bright copper color. Rich caramelized roasted pecan, chocolate gelato, and spicy chutney aromas with a silky, dry-yet-fruity medium-to-full body and a vanilla, melon sorbet, praline, and mineral finish. A great cocktail rum.

90 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Jul 2012)

Tight scents of tobacco leaf, bacon fat, walnut, lanolin, parchment and brown sugar. The palate entry is caramel sweet with touches of vanilla bean, and honey; the midpalate features pleasing tastes of nut paste, treacle, marzipan and sap. Concludes semisweet, with traces of cola nut, cotton candy and dark caramel.

85-89 points, Wine Enthusiast (Jun 2007)

$31.99

6 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Ron Centenario 9yr Conmemorativo Rum (750ml)
From San José, San José, Costa Rica

$23.99

24 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$19.99

8 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Rhum Barbancourt 8yr 5 Star Rum (750ml)
From Port-au-Prince, Ouest, Haiti

$27.99

4 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream (750ml)
From Brighton, Saint Michael, Barbados

$18.99

10 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Plantation 5yr Signature Blend Rum (750ml)
From Barbados

94WE 93TP

As might be expected from a rum affiliated with a Cognac maker, this honey-colored spirit is finished in old Cognac barrels. The end result is luxe but light, yielding caramel and orange peel aromas, as well as loads of sweet honey and creamy caramel on the palate, accented with a bright touch of lemon. Especially enjoyable mixed with ginger beer, Dark & Stormy-style.

94 points, Wine Enthusiast (Dec 2011)

Medium amber color; lovely caramel and orange peel nose; lush, creamy and sweet with lovely brown sugar, spice and honey; rich, mellow and luscious.

93 points, Tasting Panel (Jul 2012)

$26.99

5 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Ron Centenario 25yr Gran Reserva Rum (750ml)
From San José, San José, Costa Rica

$69.99

6 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Zafra 21yr Master Reserve Panama Rum (750ml)
From Panama

95BTI

Rich burnished amber copper color. Polished aromas of dried stone and tropical citrus fruits, melted toffee, vanilla, mossy river stone, and spice cake have a distinct high toned bourbon barrel quality and follow through on a smooth, satiny entry to a dry-yet-fruity medium-full body with superb depth and poise. Finishes with a long, evolving cascade of tobacco, leather, cocoa, cedar, nut, and earth nuances. An elegant, seamless aged rum for contemplative sipping, or top shelf cocktails.

95 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Jun 2010)

$54.99

7 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Thomas Tew Single Barrel Rum (750ml)
From Newport, Rhode Island

$34.99

6 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Ron Centenario 20yr Fundacion XX Anos Rum (750ml)
From San José, San José, Costa Rica

$49.99

3 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
$24.99

6 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Siesta Key Spiced Rum (750ml)
From Sarasota, Florida

91WE

Made with molasses from Florida sugarcane, with honey and spices added, this sunny golden spiced rum is smooth and pleasant, suitable for a wide range of cocktails. On the palate, the flavor is vanilla-forward and similar to cola. Yet it’s not overly sweet and allows nutmeg and cinnamon to shine through.

91 points, Wine Enthusiast (Aug 2013)

$26.99

14 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Rhum Barbancourt 15yr Reserve Speciale Rum (750ml)
From Port-au-Prince, Ouest, Haiti

$49.99

26 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Smith & Cross Traditional Jamaica Rum (750ml)
From Jamaica

95WE

A top pick for tiki and tropical drinks, this practically begs for lime juice. Scented with warm honey notes, the palate shows lots of brown sugar and spice, plus an enticingly untamed, funky finish (the fabled *hogo*). Since it's “navy strength,” you might not want to sip it straight up—the producer wisely recommends exploring the profile first in a daiquiri—though it's smooth and interesting enough if you want to try.

95 points, Kara Newman, Wine Enthusiast (Aug 2014)

$34.99

8 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1
Cruzan Black Strap Rum (750ml)
From St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands

85-89WE 87BTI

Toasty/roasted aromas of molasses, black coffee and road tar begin the nosing stage, then bittersweet scents of oatmeal stout ale, licorice, dark cocoa, pipe tobacco and brown sugar take over. Palate entry is long, more sweet than bittersweet and dark chocolate-like; at midpalate, tastes of bacon fat, oak resin and brown sugar turn creamy. Finishes smooth, creamy and dense.

85-89 points, Wine Enthusiast (May 2004)

Opaque chestnut brown color. Vibrant and distinct aromas of brown sugar and maple syrup on oatmeal are attractive and follow through on a smooth entry to a dry-yet-fruity medium body with notes of baked bananas and dates. Finishes with a peppery molasses treacle candy, nutshell, and mossy mineral fade. Should make for interesting cocktails.

87 points, Beverage Testing Institute (Jun 2010)

$17.99

13 bottles in stock and ready to ship.
1